Thalia, Heretic Cathar

Rare6 versions from Innistrad Remastered · all sets

Cheapest version$0.94TCGplayer market price

Innistrad Remastered2025

Play Booster 1 in 55 packsany version · 48% per box of 36

Collector Booster Best odds1 in 13 packsany version · 63% per box of 12

VersionPricePlay BoosterCollector Booster

Regular #44 $1.961 in 100 packs30% per box— not in this booster

Borderless · Foil #300 $2.271 in 2,240 packs1.6% per box1 in 86 packs13% per box

Foil #44 $2.061 in 747 packs4.7% per box1 in 84 packs13% per box

Borderless #300 $2.311 in 299 packs11% per box1 in 43 packs24% per box

Regular #351 $0.941 in 325 packs11% per box1 in 43 packs24% per box

Foil #351 $1.31— not in this booster1 in 86 packs13% per box

"Any version" adds up the chances of each version, so it is a close estimate.